- Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
As mentioned, there may well be as many as a dozen individual Spratly Islands that are claimed by four countries. But, though not all the claims are crystal
Apr 22, 2004 @ 14:08 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
so our magnificent sunken quinticountry obelisk along with all the other sunken treasure & beauty of louisa reef & of our beloved everyones land in general
Sep 04, 2004 @ 14:46 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
Do we know the origin of this obelisk? Is it perhaps a memorial to those shipwrecked on the reef? Lowell G. McManus Leesville, Louisiana, USA ... From:
Sep 04, 2004 @ 16:59 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
i think more likely than a memorial would be someones idea of a territorial marker functioning perhaps much like a boundary monument only without any boundary
Sep 04, 2004 @ 19:15 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
On the page at http://www.panagadivers.com/Diving/Reefs.htm , there are 1993 and 2003 photos of the obelisk, and there s a 2002 photo at
Sep 04, 2004 @ 21:25 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
& the height to breadth ratio of the tapered part of the obelisk has apparently diminished substantially between 1993 & 2003 lending a hair more credence to
Sep 04, 2004 @ 22:41 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
I d like to see what the inscriptions are (or at least an account of what is written on the marker). I wonder if a country s name has been removed while
Sep 04, 2004 @ 22:45 - Michael Kaufman (Michael Kaufman <mikekaufman79@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
A web site at http://www.mir.com.my/potpourri/places/mpwong/destination/louisa/ says of Louisa Reef, The navigation beacon at its southwest point is now
Sep 05, 2004 @ 01:32 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
You are correct. I read the date wrong and didn t even notice the date on the shirt. Lowell G. McManus Leesville, Louisiana, USA ... From: Michael Kaufman
Sep 05, 2004 @ 01:36 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
well no need to postulate a greater mystery in order to solve a lesser one & i think a single 5country obelisk in the sea is plenty for the time being the so
Sep 06, 2004 @ 18:47 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
Each theory is as good as the other. Do we know for fact that the lighthouse or navigation beacon was Malaysian, or is that theory too? Lowell G. McManus
Sep 07, 2004 @ 03:50 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
yes we have had this report at least since message 14049 when i still imagined she was only a 4country reef see under louisa in alphabetical list of spratlys
Sep 07, 2004 @ 13:55 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
Why not 6 country with Philippines? ... __________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - You care about security. So do we.
Sep 08, 2004 @ 03:41 - Michael Kaufman (Michael Kaufman <mikekaufman79@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
tho the philippines do claim several of the spratly islands & tho all 6 bncnmyphtwvn countries claim at least 1 spratly each the philippines dont claim louisa
Sep 08, 2004 @ 05:05 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
The map in the link says nothing about Taiwan and Louisa Reef as far as I can see. And it looks like it falls outside the Vietnam Petroleum Block Claim. On
Sep 11, 2004 @ 01:21 - Michael Kaufman (Michael Kaufman <mikekaufman79@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
... true but taiwan claims all the spratlys with no known exceptions just as do china & vietnam so i have assumed each of their claims includes louisa reef &
Sep 11, 2004 @ 02:45 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
I agree that the map at http://cat.middlebury.edu/southchinasea/macand/ shows Louisa Reef outside the Vietnamese claim, but not outside the Taiwanese claim.
Sep 11, 2004 @ 03:02 - Lowell G. McManus ("Lowell G. McManus" <mcmanus71496@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
so i still think i was right to say louisa reef with 5 claimants is the hottest real estate on earth tho not necessarily the hottest real estate under the sea
Sep 11, 2004 @ 03:29 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
Ok, if CN, VN, and TW claim all of the islands and water then that makes sense. So a 5-country-claimed reef. And then we do have that small piece of ocean as
Sep 11, 2004 @ 03:44 - Michael Kaufman (Michael Kaufman <mikekaufman79@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
right if it exists & whatever it means this is a 6country quadrilateral rather than a 6country pentagon & thus it has only 24 countrysides rather than 30 oops
Sep 11, 2004 @ 04:04 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
on this map the putative sexicountry claim area has a different shape http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/images/schinasea.jpg but note here also the differences
Sep 11, 2004 @ 16:14 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
i should have mentioned this is a cia map circa 2002 but hard to find so possibly disavowed later & i dont know whether to prefer the fresher & coarser cia
Sep 11, 2004 @ 19:27 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)
- Re: [BoundaryPoint] Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
It looks to me like (on this map) barely both NW and SE corners are cut off making it a five sided figure. But if this is the case it can t be a polygon since
Sep 12, 2004 @ 03:01 - Michael Kaufman (Michael Kaufman <mikekaufman79@...>)
- Re: Possible BNCNMYTWVN 5-Country Reef and Obelisk
good thanx for the confirmation but all of the 5 sides of this pentagon are technically arcs & polygons can be arcuate as well as rectilinear as well as mixed
Sep 12, 2004 @ 03:07 - aletheiak ("aletheiak" <aletheiak@...>)