I am a serious birder/lister and also have a strong interest in boundaries
and tripoints. Last week on Tuesday (June 4) I visited the place where
Germany, Belgium, and Luxembourg come together, and got into some real
trivia of bird listing and boundaries. The Germany-Luxembourg border is
very unusual, in that where it follows the rivers Our, Sure/Sauer, and
Moselle, the rivers are condominia under the joint sovereignty of Germany
and Luxembourg. So the question for European bird listing enthusiasts is,
on what list(s) can I count birds seen on or flying above the condominium
rivers? Both countries? Or neither country but a separate condominium area
list? Or what? I did not see a Mute Swan in Luxembourg proper, only on the
rivers.
At the tripoint where Belgium, Germany, and Luxembourg meet, near Ouren,
Belgium, I saw a Dipper. First, it was flying up the middle of the small
brook ("Rippach") which defines the Belgium-Luxembourg boundary. As far as
I know the boundary also follows the middle of the brook, so the bird
probably had its left wine in Luxembourg and its right wing in Belgium.
A little later it flew back down the brook, cut across the field a little
(all in Luxembourg at that point), and then flew down the middle of the
Our, being simultaneously 100% in both Germany and in Luxembourg, or
perhaps in neither. I had seen Dipper previously in Germany, and briefly
it was entirely over land than was Luxembourg, but the right half of this
Dipper was the only part of a Dipper I ever saw in Belgium.
Has any reader had a similar experience anywhere?
David
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
David M. Mark
Amherst, New York (near Buffalo; home location)
dmark@...
http://www.geog.buffalo.edu/~dmark/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------