Subject: Re: clavoscopy of everyones land advances
Date: Aug 15, 2001 @ 22:07
Author: Grant Hutchison ("Grant Hutchison" <granthutchison@...>)
Prev    Post in Topic    Next [All Posts]
Prev    Post in Time    Next


Michael:
> do these holes appear to be shaping up & amounting to another golf
course or
> anything at this point
You'll remember we got into an unresolved debate about the precise
maritime claims of the French in the Southern and Antarctic Lands.
For the sake of moving forward on Everyone's Land, I think the
Principle of Maximum Greed I used to draw the global maps is useful -
if we assume that everyone will somehow and eventually claim all the
ocean surface they can get their hands on, then we can map what
remains outside the UN terms, and this is most definitely Everyone's
Land. So the following is the list of 19 (going on 20) island
enclaves that appear on the global EEZ views.
====================================================
Atlantic Ocean:
1. Ascension (UK)
2. Azores (Portugal)
3. Bermuda (UK)
4. Bouvet Island (Norway)
5. Saint Helena (UK)
6. Shag Rocks to South Sandwich Islands (UK)
7. Trindade & Martin Vaz Islands (Brazil)
8. Tristan da Cunha group (UK)

Indian Ocean:
1. Amsterdam & Saint Paul Islands (France)
2. Cocos (Keeling) Islands (Australia)
3. Crozet Islands (France)
4. Heard & McDonald Islands (Australia) and Kerguelen Islands (France)
5. Prince Edward Islands (South Africa)


Pacific Ocean:
1. Clipperton Island (France)
2. Desventurados Islands: San Ambrosio, San Felix (Chile)
3. Easter & Sala y Gomez Islands (Chile)
4. Johnston Atoll (USA)
5. Midway to Hawaii (USA)
6. Minami-tori Island (Japan)

Note:
The Kermadec Islands (New Zealand) are connected to the general
E.E.Z. only by two dubious claims: L'Esperance Rock and South Minerva
Reef, and therefore form a seventh potential Pacific island enclave.
==========================================

If we gain the Kermadecs, we lose the South Fiji Basin, which would
be opened to the high seas by the formation of the Kermadecs EEZ
island. We could also lose the South Fiji Basin *without* gaining the
Kermadecs, if only one or the other of the dodgy EEZ claims
connecting it to the EEZ "mainland" were disallowed.

I think we can be pretty sure that there are no second-order EEZ
enclaves - all of the islands listed above are adrift on the general
high seas, and none of the ocean enclaves are large enough to contain
a 200nm EEZ, with the exception of the Arctic, which has no central
islands, rocks or reefs to raise doubt.
(I'll upload this list as a Word document to the files area, to
complement the ocean enclave list and the maps already there.)

Grant