Subject: RE: [BoundaryPoint] Re: BoundaryPoint and borders
Date: Sep 03, 2003 @ 22:27
Author: Flynn, Kevin ("Flynn, Kevin" <flynnk@...>)
Prev    Post in Topic    Next [All Posts]
Prev    Post in Time    Next


I guess a reason that might not be a solution is that, as someone else
mentioned here, IBRG is more highly specialized than the types of border
discussions some of us have wanted to have. Here is the intro from
intborder's home page:

"The International Border Research Group (IBRG) is studying international
borders and publishing the results. Membership is available for researchers,
writers and other professionals especially interested in border expeditions.
Every year the IBRG is arranging an international border expedition. From
9th - 21st July 2003 The Great Baltic Border Expedition (GBBE) was taking
place."

What if we are not "especially interested" in making actual expeditions to
international borders? Or have desire to discuss non-international borders
(states, provinces, others?) of the type more appropriate to boundary
points? Some of us cannot make such expeditions for many reasonable
circumstances.

-----Original Message-----
From: m06079 [mailto:barbaria_longa@...]
Sent: Wednesday, September 03, 2003 3:55 PM
To: BoundaryPoint@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [BoundaryPoint] Re: BoundaryPoint and borders


jesper
thanxxx for being here & for all of these reflections & especially
for the great part of them that i do understand & agree with

but what i dont understand about what you are saying & polling
is that i thought we all just recently finished creating
featuring promoting nurturing commending exhorting saluting
priming & finally opening to everyone our only true sister group
ibrg
both by announcements on our bp home page & over the course
of many months of messages
& indeed i thought we did all this particularly because ibrg is
already expressly & fully devoted to borders
& so people who are interested in both multipoints in particular &
borders in general could subscribe to both groups
& indeed they & you have subscribed to both groups

& moreover i thought we did all this especially so as to be able to
relax about the admittedly difficult question you are again raising

so i still dont get what all the commotion is about


why dont we just use our existing second group for the purposes
we intended it for

& why would we need to even think about creating yet another
group at this point


perhaps just maintaining an affirmation of ibrg on the bp home
page with a referral of general border freaks to it
& perhaps adding a corresponding affirmation of bp to the ibrg
home page with a referral back to bp for the only slightly strange
multipointer individuals
is all we really need to do now
to ice & decorate our otherwise already fully effective freak & nut
layer cake

& welcome back jan

--- In BoundaryPoint@yahoogroups.com, "Jesper Nielsen"
<jesniel@i...> wrote:
> Dear fellow multipointers and border freaks
>
> BoundaryPoint has changed my life. It sounds like a cliche, but
the truth is that without this group I would never have seen or
attempted 24 international tripoints, or probably been the first to
visit all DK county tripoints. I would also not have had the large
volume of knowledge of international borders that I have today,
all thanks to you. Without BoundaryPoint there wouldn't have
been a Border Crossing Hitlist or BorderBase, etc. etc.
>
> But my interests for border and boundaries do go beyound
multipoints. I would much rather visit the dry BGRO than the very
wet BGCSRO at the other end. Not that I would miss BGCSRO
though.
>
> But BoundaryPoint is not really a border group, it's a multipoint
group. And border discussions have been much noise in the
group for very long. And we need to respect the group founders
and owners intentions.
>
> So, I have created a poll, so see if creating a sister group to
BoundaryPoint is wanted. This happens all the time, one topic
fills up too much in a group, and so a sub- or sister group has
been established, no hard feelings here.
>
> If a sister group is wanted, I will offcourse subscribe to both
groups, as they are not competition, but sisters.
>
> But I just feel I need a place where I can post questions and
share thoughs and material about borders in general.
>
> All the best
>
> Jesper





Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/