Subject: ok so where are we
Date: May 01, 2001 @ 09:22
Author: michael donner (michael donner <m@...>)
Prev    Post in Topic    Next
Prev    Post in Time    Next


congrats all around on a propitious beginning

so far
we have one mereotopology of claves based on political boundaries alone
& another based on the boundaries plus any associated water separations
& perhaps a third one if anyone likes based only on water separations

& there may be other members yet to be heard from with still other schemes


& so long as we can distinguish the various schemes from one another
clarity reigns


naming each scheme simply & unmistakably might help
as might using different terms within each scheme
as might considering each scheme in turn separately
& we appear to be well on the way to doing all these things


but it seems to me that before we can proceed much further with the claves
we need to return again to the countries themselves
to consider what a country is & which countries we are going to include
& which countries or what in the world if anything we are going to ignore
since what we seem to be talking about is parts & their wholes


or are there other & higher priorities i am missing

m