Subject: Re: Is any part of Peru North of the Equator?
Date: Jul 29, 2002 @ 21:07
Author: ps1966nl ("ps1966nl" <smaardijk@...>)
Prev    Post in Topic    Next [All Posts]
Prev    Post in Time    Next


Grant wrote:
"(...)The interesting bit started when I looked in Biger, who has a
rather different run for the border, albeit farther south. I've
attached a bmp scan of his map. He describes this as the border
following the Putumayo "... to its confluence with one of its
tributaries, the Güeppi River. The boundary line follows that river
upstream westwards for about 25 miles (40km) and meets the boundary
junction with Ecuador northwest of the small Colombian town of Cabo
Reyes." This makes no sense in terms of the map, which shows the
border striking off overland and meeting the Güeppi at the tripoint.
This is compounded by the entry for the Colombia-Ecuador border which
states: "The eastern terminus of the boundary is located on the the
Güeppi River, west of the small town of Cabo Minacho (Ecuador). It
follows the river downstream eastwards to its confluence with the
Putumayo River ..."
Taken together, these seem to imply that the two borders run
alongside each other in the Güeppi River between the tripoint (40km
upstream) and the confluence with the Putumayo (where most maps
apparently plot the tripoint).
So ... in answer to your question, I think that Peru doesn't extend
north of the Putumayo River, which doesn't go north of the equator
along the Colombia-Peruvian border. But beyond that I haven't the
foggiest notion where the border goes!
Anyone?"

This map in Biger is strange indeed. I think that the tripoint is
indeed at the confluence of Putumayo and Güeppí rivers. Cf. e.g.
http://www.tsi.com.pe/libroblanco/comunicaciones.doc , where it says
that Peru possesses the right bank of the Putumayo between the Güeppí
and the Yahuas. Cf. also the map at
http://www.adonde.com/historia/1999_peru_ecuador.htm . This map is
different from the DeLorme one, by the way, at the spot where an area
previously in dispute is shown (and the difference at DeLorme's map
is not due to this dispute, it seems)!

Cf. also http://www.rree.gob.pe/polexter/peruecu/mapas/mapa09.gif (a
Peruvian foreign office site on Peru/Ecuador relations reg. the border
(http://www.rree.gob.pe/polexter/peruecu/mapas/default.htm));
unfortunately most of the maps here can't be reached because the
links are broken).

Biger's version of things to me is questionable, to say the least.
But I have to concede that I only have seen things being presented in
the Peruvian way on the web...

Peter S.