Subject: brownlie reaches cream hill for my birthday
Date: Feb 01, 2006 @ 23:21
Author: aletheia kallos (aletheia kallos <aletheiak@...>)
Prev    Post in Topic    Next
Prev    Post in Time    Next


this among other delights
eventually
since i get a whole month with him

you may recall the question that provoked his recall
from the uconn library was
but why suppose an eglysd datum has ever been stated
or even can be synthesized

& it was asked in order to both pinpoint the eglysd
position as well as possible and to classify a visit
try & pic made by gpsrs in wgs84 at 14m range
based on establishing the wgs84 meridian of the
nearest egly monument & then projecting its
intersection with the wgs84 22nd parallel
which is believed to be as yet uncommitted by any egsd
demarcation in the way the 25th meridian has been
committed by the egly demarcation


& under egly he says
not surprisingly
ibs number 61 notes that from the coast the boundary
is demarcated for some 206 miles
out of approximately 693 miles
& thus it is the straightline sector which is largely
undemarcated
but he then adds his recurrent proviso

the fixing of geometrical lines on the ground involves
close survey work
& local adjustments are often necessary to give
practical sense to the frontier

yikes
as if to anticipate & preclude our proposed 487 mile
extrapolation methodology

perhaps

for i am not sure if i am reading too much into this

but lets assume that i am & that there really is no
objection to our hypothetical procedure

which feels better already


in any case
he then continues
now unsurprisingly again
demarcation occurred in 1926 & 1927 & adjustments in
1938
& he quotes from a 1950 survey of egypt report as
follows

in 1938 at the request of the frontiers administration
the survey erected 187 permanent concrete beacons to
define the frontier between egypt & the then italian
colony of libya
&
this work was carried on down to latitude 29
into the sand dune area south of the siwa jaghbub
depression
&
20 special beacons
rather smaller than the first 167
were constructed therein upon rocky outcrops by the
survey
&
an egypto italian boundary commission inspected each
of these beacons in april 1938
& signed a proces verbal confirming their replacement
of the temporary marks which up til then had defined
the frontier

note thats evidently the southernmost 20 rocks rather
than just some unspecified 9 mentioned in the ibs
& the date of the proces verbal is given as 3may1939
rather than 3may1938 in the ibs

unimportant details perhaps unless one is looking for
them

but it seems this is the document that will tell us or
lead us to the coords in some datum of the final
dwarfish rock atop the last outcrop among the dunes

the only catch is
neither brownlie nor the ibs tells us where to find
this document

however it still may not matter because what brownlie
does mention in his egly bibliography is the 1928
atlas of egypt by the survey of egypt
which thus could also suffice for our exercise by
giving the locations of the temporary marks

so if any of you map curators or other academics
happen to be in reach of a copy of that baby
well you & thus we may already hold the keys to
unlocking eglysd









__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com