Subject: Re: [BoundaryPoint] Belize-Guatemala Border
Date: Nov 11, 2000 @ 22:01
Author: michael donner (michael donner <m@...>)
Prev Post in Topic Next [All Posts]
Prev Post in Time Next
> Some interesting events surrounding the Belize/Guatemala border...
>The first 3 stories from Belize's "The Reporter" newspaper. The final one
>from Channel 5 Belize Television. ***Milestone agreement for Belize
>and GuatemalaThe Organization of American State Permanent Council this
>week approved aresolution, proposed by delegations from both Guatemala
>and Belize forfurther confidence-building measures over the ongoing
>territorial dispute.Assad Shoman, Senior Ambassador with ministerial rank
>represented Belizeduring a session of the OAS Permanent Council held on
>Wednesday, November8, at the OAS headquarters in Washington
>D.C.Representing Guatemala was its foreign minister Gabriel (Orellana
>Rojas.Both men signed an agreement to adopt a comprehensive set
>ofconfidence-building measures to avoid further incidents between the
>twocountries.OAS Secretary General Cesar Gaviria, congratulated both
>countries for themilestone agreement their delegation has reached so far
>in their quest fora peaceful settlement over the dispute." This is a very
>significant step that clears the way for the negotiationson the substance
>of the differendum to be addressed in a climate of mutualconfidence and
>tranquility for both governments and for the people livingin the area. It
>faithfully reflects the commitment of both parties to theprocess and
>their will for peace," Secretary General Gaviria said.Based on the
>proposal, the OAS went ahead and approved a resolution thatsupports the
>process of negotiation. It has also established a special fundto support
>the negotiation by financing the costs of the work of the panelof
>facilitators in the dialogue." The decision of the Permanent Council
>underlines the commitment of theOAS to continue promoting and supporting
>the peaceful resolution ofdisputes between member states," Gaviria
>said.***BDF in morale crisisCommandant designate dismisses internal
>gripesGuatemala's continuous unfounded claim to Belizean soil along with
>reportsof serious tension among its ranks, is causing great concern for
>the menand women in the Belize Defence Force."We are suffering in
>silence. There is a serious situation that we have todeal with from the
>outside, as well as serious internal problems thatcontinue to go
>unnoticed with-in the BDF," said one of two high ranking BDFofficers and a
>private who Reporter interviewed this week."Our soldiers are sitting on a
>time bomb. There is frustration anddisappointment on a day-to-day basis.
>There will come a point when oursoldiers, out of frustration, will show
>absolutely no respect to us at thesenior level, and unfortunately nothing
>is being done to address theseproblems," expressed a calm but serious top
>BDF officer.The tension, they said, became even more intense after the
>apprehension byGuatemalan soldiers, of three of their soldiers and a
>police officer inFebruary of this year. "Border patrols were suspended
>after the apprehension of the four securitypersonnel. After these men were
>freed on bail in Guatemala, they jumpedbail and returned to Belize. The
>decision to have them jump bail, couldescalate into serious impact on our
>soldiers who are patrolling theBelize/Guatemalan borderline."Our soldiers
>are patrolling in fear, as a result of this situation. Theyare greatly
>concerned that should they come across a platoon of Guatemalansoldiers,
>which numbers forty strong and who are well equipped withammunition, it
>is likely that they could be easily overpowered and takeninto Guatemala,
>with the high possibility of being charged and jailed," onetop official
>said.Commandant designate of the BDF, Colonel Cedrick Borland, refuted
>theseallegations and painted a rosier picture of what he described as
>progressin the BDF. He conceded that there exist certain threats along
>the borderline.Colonel Borland said that the training which the soldiers
>go throughrequires them to achieve a certain level of readiness. He said
>that thereis a refresher's course that soldiers participate in, and this
>keeps themup with certain standard."Our soldiers have been trained to
>deal with these situations and trainingis a continuous process to ensure
>that our soldiers are kept in the higheststandard," Col. Borland said.The
>soldiers meanwhile expressed concern that they have been placed in
>ahostile environment.And with the lack of necessary technical support,
>due to limited resources,no systematic plans are in place should they
>encounter a situation with theaggressive Guatemalan military."There is
>only one vehicle in operation for the BDF base in Toledo. AtTreetop,
>there are eight of us, and another group are out on patrol. Howare we
>going to be assisted should an incident or accident occur if thatonly
>vehicle is not available? There is not even a backup system in place,"one
>explained.Col. Borland refuted this claim, stating that there are two
>vehiclesavailable at Fairweather Camp.Another problem cited is the lack
>of communication in the BDF. Soldierssaid they are rarely informed of new
>developments in the BDF. "We usuallyhear of these developments through
>the media. We were never informed of theappointment of a new commandant.
>We were never told that the Guatemalanswere very upset over the removal
>of the flag from Santa Rosa," one of thetop official said.As to the
>removal of the flag from the school in Santa Rosa, the soldierssaid that
>they had to remove the flag during nighttime, when the villagerswere
>already in their homes.One soldier says that just recently they came
>across an illegal Guatemalansettlement in an area known as Retiro, in the
>Cayo district. When theyapproached the settlers and informed them that
>they have to return toGuatemala, the settlers told them boldly that they
>were not moving, unlessthey are told by the Guatemalan military to do so.
>"These settlers arestill there," he said.The soldiers also complained of
>living in deplorable conditions and of thedisrespect shown them by the
>Ministry of National Security.Col. Borland was more optimism in the BDF,
>and said that there is goodcommunication within the BDF. He said that
>much improvement has been takingplace at the Fairweather Camp and the two
>observation posts in the ToledoDistrict.****A Big Thing!Guatemala claims
>Belize disrespectful of her flagGuatemala is making a big thing over the
>actions of the BDF in taking downa Guatemalan flag which was being flown
>at an illegal settlement withinBelizean borders.The Guatemalan
>squatters were told to leave and the flag was removed. Itwas later
>delivered over to the Guatemalan Embassy in Belize City.The Prensa Libre
>newspaper of Sunday, November 5 reports what happenedlater. President
>Portillo organized a Flag Tribute ceremony with militaryguard of honour
>and senior members of the government, including ForeignMinister
>Orellana.The dignitaries at the ceremony included the Presidents of the
>Judiciaryand the Legislature, Hugo Maul Figueroa and Efrain Rios Montt.
>The flag wasturned over to the Minister of Defence, Juan de Dios Estrada,
>whosubsequently delivered it to the Minister of Education, Mario
>Torres.Torres is to attend a flag-raising ceremony at the opening of the
>newschool year (2001) for students of Santa Rosa School in Peten. The
>ceremonyis to be accompanied by a 21-gun salute.Orellana said during a
>speech he made on this occasion that it was sheerinsanity to pretend to
>stain the honour of the Guatemalan flag.He said that Guatemala was
>sending a message to Belize and to the worldthat Guatemala would defend
>her homeland ("su tierra y su hogar")!Orellana added: "The government of
>Belize realized the error it hadcommitted, and in response to the just
>Guatemalan protest, had returnedthe patriotic symbol."Ambassador Jorge
>Skinner Klee made a special trip from Belize to take theflag back to
>Guatemala. He handed it over to President Alfonso Portillo.The elaborate
>ceremony was held at the Guatemalan Air Force base in
>thecapital.Ambassador Skinner Klee also took the opportunity while in
>Guatemala toreport that his Embassy in Belize had received a bomb threat.
>He said alsothat the consulate in Belize had been the target of "criminal
>acts", namelyrobberies involving the property of Guatemalan diplomats.The
>Prensa Libre notes that Guatemala is claiming 12.272 square kilometersof
>land from Belize.It provided no details as to what part of the country
>the Guatemalans now want.Prensa Libre reported also that during the last
>three years, incursions bythe Belize military have intensified against
>settlements in the provinceof Peten.***From Channel 5: Details released
>of Belize-Guatemala agreement
>More details have become available on the agreement signed Wednesday
>between Belize and Guatemala. The twelve point document, signed at OAS
>headquarters in Washington D.C., deals solely with confidence building
>measures that will be undertaken by both countries along their common
>border.
>Article one lays the groundwork by stipulating that the measures outlined
>in the document are temporary for the purpose of easing tensions and do
>not prejudice any claims to sovereignty by either country over any
>territory, now or in the future.
>Article two states that unless extended by mutual agreement, these
>measures expire on August thirty-first, 2001.
>Article three, while noting one and two, specifies recognition of what is
>called an "adjacency line." Coincidentally, this adjacency line exactly
>follows the traditional borderline from Gracias a Dios in the south to
>Garbutt's Falls and Aguas Turbias in the north. Use of the line, however,
>does not imply that it represents an international boundary.
>Under article four, the parties agree to identify all existing markers and
>survey the line. They will also identify all settlements within one
>kilometre on each side.
>Article five specifies that this two kilometre wide swath of land shall be
>called the "adjacency zone."
>Article six, the real meat of the agreement, deals with how things will be
>run in the adjacency zone, namely: all settlements which existed in the
>zone as of October first of this year shall remain undisturbed, save for
>marijuana farms. Those settlements established after October first and
>lie east of the line may be removed by the Belize Government, using a set
>procedure. All settlers in the zone prior to October first will be
>identified and their nationality documented. Any Guatemalans residing on
>the Belize side of the line and any Belizeans on the Guatemalan side will
>be issued a license to stay and are bound to respect the laws of the
>country on the particular side of the line where they reside.
>Additionally, Guatemala will undertake a campaign to dissuade its
>citizens from settling to the east of the adjacency line, and at the same
>time the two countries' military forces will co-ordinate their activities
>in the area.
>Articles seven through eleven obligate the two countries to promote
>community contacts across the line, facilitate traffic and meet regularly
>to avoid conflicts. These measures will include the prevention of
>incidents, which could cause tension, and the formulation of plans for a
>response to natural disasters.
>Finally, article twelve asks the parties to monitor the confidence
>building measures and work together to resolve any problems. If that
>proves difficult, then any contentious issues should be referred to the
>two facilitators who may, if they wish, ask the OAS to appoint a
>fact-finding mission.
>The facilitator for Belize is Sir Shridath Ramphal, while Guatemala has
>appointed Paul Reichler. The agreement was signed in Washington, D.C. by
>Belizean Ambassador Assad Shoman and Guatemalan Foreign Minister Gabriel
>Orellana.
>
>Cheers!
>
>
>
>Doug
>
>
> eGroups Sponsor
>* * * BoundaryPoint shortcuts * * *
>Post new message: BoundaryPoint@egroups.com
>Subscribe: BoundaryPoint-subscribe@egroups.com
>Unsubscribe: BoundaryPoint-unsubscribe@egroups.com
>List owner: BoundaryPoint-owner@egroups.com
>URL to main page: <http://www.egroups.com/group/BoundaryPoint>
>http://www.egroups.com/group/BoundaryPoint
>